Sankha Guha.WRITER & BROADCASTER
← THE COLLECTIONHONG KONG / CHINA / TAIWAN

Stars rising in the East

Stars rising in the East

THE INDEPENDENT18 APRIL 2004
Illustrative stock photographs · Wikimedia Commons

The 8th arrondissement of Paris has 22 restaurants with Michelin stars, six of them have three stars. The whole of Hong Kong has none. This is because the Michelin Guide, the undisputed authority which makes (and breaks) the reputations not only of individual chefs and restaurants, but of entire cities, does not do the world.

The Michelin system started in France. It appeared in Britain 30 years ago for the first time – and we have been mesmerised by the lustre of those stars ever since. For better or worse, twenty European countries are now subject to the gastronomic rule of Michelin. The rest of the world is not on their map. If the Michelin Guides were simply a travel guide – it would not matter. But the restaurant star system has become the gold standard of culinary excellence and its Eurocentric (let’s be honest, blatantly French biased) flavour is out of time.

Hong Kong is on my list of top five gastro destinations. Eating out is a rite – reverentially observed three times a day (more if possible) by devout residents of the territory. The finest and freshest ingredients are flown in from Australia, Europe and the rest of Asia. So are chefs – 9 starred heavyweight Alain Ducasse opened a fusion restaurant recently. In Tsim Sha Tsui you will find sashimi to rival anything served up in Tokyo, and in Central the pizza crust is as thin and crunchy as Naple’s finest.

Every ranking world cuisine is represented – Vietnamese, Spanish, Indian, Thai and that’s before you get started on the infinite variety of regional Chinese such as Sichuanese and Shanghainese. And of course there are literally hundreds of first class Cantonese eating dens.

Yet the boss man at Michelin is adamant that France is the epicentre of Planet Food. Director Derek Brown (sacre bleu! an Englishman) points to the starry 8th arrondissement and insists Paris is still No1 – “No city in the world has so many good restaurants in such a tiny area.” He, and Michelin, should get out a bit more.

Great Towers of China

What is it with the Chinese and tall buildings? Not just tall, but monstrous great phalluses rising into the skies above the cities of the far east. Seven out of ten of the world’s tallest buildings are in effect Chinese – sprouting in Taiwan, the People’s Republic and in Hong Kong. Three different political systems with one vertiginous obsession.

Highest of the lot is Taiwan’s Taipei 101 (508m) which is due to open later this year, while mainland China has staked its virility on the Jin Mao Building (421m) in Shanghai and in Hong Kong the just completed International Finance Centre (IFC) 2 (412m) stands dominant in a skyline already crowded with giant erections. Are these tall buildings really necessary or are they the architectural equivalent of tiger penis soup?

Last week I was invited to look over the IFC and the stats came thick and fast. The complex on the waterfront at Central cost 3 billion US dollars, it will have 4.7 million square feet of floor space, the first 6 star hotel in Hong Kong, another humungous shopping mall and the biggest car park in the world. 150,000 worker ants will busy themselves in the 88 storeys of IFC2. But cold figures do not convey the emotional compulsion to reach for the skies.

Economic doldrums, the SARS epidemic and even the appalling precedent of September 11th have not interrupted the building spree. There seems to be an inevitability to these towering structures – they represent the collective will of the Chinese who will live, work and play in them. They symbolise economic muscle and, who knows, maybe fecundity itself.

A little footnote though – last month a far east TV network conducted a playful poll asking viewers what they feared most and the response came as something of a surprise – heights.

Cool or Cold?

The boutique hotel has been late arriving in Hong Kong. Maybe it’s because the city is already awash with some of the most luxurious hotels in the world – the Shangri La, the Peninsula and the Mandarin – but they represent the last word in old school style and service. Cool and fun they ’aint.

JIA, a 25 storey apartment hotel designed predictably by Philppe Starck, has just opened in the grungy surroundings of Causeway Bay and is aimed according to their blurb at the “Hip Crowd”. No harbour or peak views here. This is HK’s urban beat, neon flashy and 24/7 – a neighbourhood for “fast living professionals” to assert their funky otherness in.

Anyone familiar with London’s St Martin’s Lane Hotel will recognise the Starck signature straight off in the lobby. The pools of light, the translucent white sheer curtains, the curvy but unyielding aluminium chairs and the smattering of ‘witty’ ethnic and kitsch antique doo-dahs are all here, ever so artfully arranged. But it’s a bit mini and scaled down and lacking in drama.

In the rooms the same sense of claustrophobia persists. High gloss metal furniture with hard edges on which you might catch your shins, is accompanied by virgin white everything. The famous Starck ‘wit’ is looking dated – are you really amused by the garden gnome stool? Or the industrial rococo dining chairs? JIA means ‘home’ in Mandarin – but this home is not so much cool, as cold.

I am a great fan of the boutique hotel – the Clarence in Dublin and the Three Sisters in Tallinn get my vote every time – but with rates here starting at 2000 HK dollars (UK £143) a night comparable with the grand establishments uptown, it’s back to the pomp and circumstance of the 55th floor of the Shang. It’s cosier up here.

■
THE ORIGINAL PUBLICATION

From the
archive.

PUBLICATION
The Independent
ISSUE
18 April 2004
DESTINATION
Hong Kong / China / Taiwan

Text from Sankha Guha’s copy for the Independent on Sunday column, filed 15 April 2004. The issue date is the Sunday that followed.

Text preserved from the collected articles. Prices, contact details and travel information reflect the original publication. Publication dates do not establish exact travel dates.

PREVIOUS STORY · 04 April 2004Sankha Guha: Man About World — Going to hellRead story ↗NEXT STORY · 25 April 2004Sankha Guha: Man About World — Detain us at Heathrow? Spare meRead story ↗