Sankha Guha.WRITER & BROADCASTER
← THE COLLECTIONVARIOUS DESTINATIONS

Cities: the true meaning of travel

Sankha Guha selects his favourite cities for the tourist who wants to experience the true meaning of travel.

FINANCIAL TIMES25 JANUARY 2003
Illustrative stock photographs · Wikimedia Commons

Who wants to escape? Who needs to get away from it all? Not me.

The swaying palms and golden sands of holiday-brochure land leave me cold. No, give me the adrenalin surge of a six-lane highway speeding into the heart of a new metropolis. Give me landscapes crafted by the tricks and foibles of man, give me canyons of soaring glass and steel, and skylines of neon.

From the Arctic Circle to the Sahara desert, people have tamed hostile environments with breathtaking imagination and resourcefulness. And the cities we have built are so much more than bricks and mortar, they are an inexhaustible store of culture, food, architecture, romance and invention. If you can have all that, sitting on a beach seems such an insipid waste of a holiday.

Few of us feel entirely comfortable with the idea of being tourists. The more we travel en masse, the less connection we make with our surroundings. Package holidays cocoon us from the very things that make travel worthwhile.

Local culture is reduced to sad little performances by folkloric groups at the poolside. Resort food bears no resemblance to anything local people eat. Even the souvenirs are likely to have been mass produced in a factory in China, unless, of course, you are visiting China. In which case, they are entirely likely to have been imported from a sweatshop in Sri Lanka.

Try as we might to convince ourselves that all this leisure travel is about going places, we are left with an uneasy sense that the experience has been eviscerated. Tourists have become customers, not explorers.

Cities give us back the adventure of travel. They're simply too big and too anarchic to be packageable. No tour operator can hope to hold back the tide of life crashing around us. The metropolis is the last wild frontier - here tourists are outnumbered, outgunned and forced to play by new rules.

Adapting to the unfamiliar is an essential prerequisite of adventure. Even if all we are dealing with is a scamming cabbie or a haggling market trader, smart travellers learn to nuance their negotiating skills depending on where they are. Successful bartering in a Marrakech souk requires a different kind of language and (more importantly) tone to a similar transaction in a street market in Bangkok.

Getting the hang of such basics is rewarding, but it's only the beginning. To develop a taste for the urban adventure, pick a city which challenges your preconceptions head on.

Tokyo is the largest conurbation in the world, a dense mass of humanity, living in closer proximity to each other than some western sociologists think is good for us. They argue such alienating concrete environments lead inevitably to disaffected youth and so to menace on the streets.

This may seem self-evident in London's Peckham or the South Bronx, but it's not a universal truth. Tokyo's disaffected youth tends to lock itself into its bedroom rather than join street-gangs or become addicted to crack. Here you can find yourself walking down an unlit backstreet at 3am and, becoming aware of another presence, glance over your shoulder to find you are being followed not by a mugger but by a solitary unconcerned teenage girl clattering home in high heels.

Don't apply the same street logic in Brazil. A friend of mine, a travel writer who really should have known better, came back from a week in Rio having been mugged three times. Once is excusable, twice is careless, but three times is culpable. His cultural GPS had failed. He forgot where he was and, despite plenty of warning, he made no adjustment to his appearance or behaviour, toting camera, watch and wallet with imperial aloofness. In Rio, this marked him out as a day-glo target.

Being recognisably foreign is not always a bad thing. One of the joys of raiding someone else's home-town is the way you are indulged, often treated as a kind of celebrity. Everything you say carries the weight of an ambassador, people listen, and your opinion is respected even on matters you had hitherto never considered. Suddenly your take on EU expansion, US foreign policy, and UK football rises above a pub rant and becomes statesmanlike.

Being a licensed outsider also means you can ask naive questions and get deep answers. In Bangkok, I asked a poor canal-side dweller if he resented tourists gawping into his home, snapping away on their expensive cameras, as they made their way to the floating market.

He replied that as a Buddhist, he could not resent these intruders because they must have been very virtuous in previous lives to be so privileged now. He hoped, if he was very good in this life, to come back as a tourist.

I, too, want to return as a tourist. One who recognises that the true value of travel lies in other people. Sartre got it so wrong with that aphorism: "Hell is other people." Some of us travel to hell, for hell's sake, and to be surrounded by hell. It's other people who make this planet infinitely interesting. And cities are where you find them.

* Sankha Guha is the editor/author of '24 Hours in the City : Tallinn', the first in a series of city guides in Europe. It can be ordered online from www.24hours-in.com

■
THE ORIGINAL PUBLICATION

From the
archive.

PUBLICATION
Financial Times
ISSUE
25 January 2003
DESTINATION
Various destinations

Source: author’s newspaper cutting.

Text preserved from the collected articles. Prices, contact details and travel information reflect the original publication. Publication dates do not establish exact travel dates.

PREVIOUS STORY · 28 April 2002Tallinn's Euro visionRead story ↗NEXT STORY · 25 January 2003Flavours and flair: 10 ultimate city destinationsRead story ↗